Tag: U.S. Constitution

Why the Leak of the Draft Decision on Roe v. Wade?

Commentary The leak of a draft Supreme Court opinion potentially overruling Roe v. Wade is unprecedented. To understand the likely motives behind the leak, let’s go back in time and place. Bear with me as I review a similar case (pdf) from a half-century ago. It’s the summer of 1972. The place is the state…


Mississippi Woman Wins Lawsuit Over ‘Vague Language’ Regulating Health Coaches

A Mississippi woman has won a lawsuit against the state after health officials tried to shut down a weight-loss course she offered through her personal training business in 2020. Even though weight loss has been a topic of conversation since the dawn of the convenient, sedentary lifestyle brought with it the side effect of obesity,…


Did the Iroquois Confederation Influence the Constitution? A Myth They May Be Teaching Your Children

Commentary Some schools are teaching children that the formation of the American Union, and specifically the Constitution, were influenced heavily by the pre-existing federation of the Iroquois Indians. There are many websites making the same claim. As someone with native ancestry, I’d be glad if it were true. But it’s demonstrably false. Parents who find…


No, the Constitution Isn’t Racist Trash

Commentary The other day on “The View,” a gentleman named Elie Mystal attacked the Constitution with an argument so astute it only could have come from the mind of a Harvard educated lawyer. From the comfort of a multimillion-dollar TV show, Mystal declared that the Constitution is “kind of trash.” “It was written by slavers and…


How the Supreme Court Rewrote the Constitution

Commentary The first installment in this series explained that the Constitution created a small and frugal federal government. This didn’t change materially until the 1930s and 1940s. The second installment profiled the Supreme Court justices serving in the period 1934–1937, when the court, under the leadership of Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, attempted to balance…


The Attack on Our Constitutional Republic Cannot Go on Forever

Commentary I keep a few books close at hand as much for their titles as for their contents. Ralph Buchsbaum’s zoological classic “Animals Without Backbones” is one such volume. I always put it on my desk when writing about academic administrators in order to remind myself what species of creature I’m confronting. An even more…


How the Supreme Court Rewrote the Constitution: 1937–1944

Commentary The first installment in this series described America’s limited and frugal federal government from 1789 until the 1930s. This second installment explains how the stage was set for radical change. Crisis and Depression In October 1929, a financial bubble broke. As always happens when financial bubbles break, people lost a great deal and hardship…


Understanding the Constitution: Strict Construction, Textualism, and Originalism

Commentary Reporters and opinion writers often classify Supreme Court justices as “originalists,” “textualists,” or “strict constructionists.” And they often misuse those terms. For example, a Dec. 9 column in Slate treated all three terms as synonymous. That’s entirely wrong. This essay clarifies the three terms and how they interact. Strict Construction Strict construction is this:…


Ronald Reagan’s Warning on Freedom Is Relevant Around the Anglosphere

Commentary Ronald Reagan, one of the greatest American presidents, presciently warned about the situation in which both the U.S., Australia and much of the Anglosphere find themselves today. “Freedom,” he said, “is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. “It must be fought for,…


The Values in the Constitution

Commentary The Declaration of Independence expressed a common American creed: All are born equal before God and the law, God bestows humans with natural rights, some of these rights are unalienable (untransferable), it’s the purpose of government to secure them, and if a government incorrigibly fails to do so, the people should replace it. However,…